Debate Competition

Assessment Rubric 

ROUND 1

"TH should supports the death penalty for corruptors."

1. Opening Government (OG)

•  If the punishment just being in the jail, corruptors will not affected, they will corrupt again.
• The corruptors have stolen people's money, it's very not relevant.

2. Opening Opposition (OO)

• The death penalty is against human rights.
• There's still other options to punish them for what they've done because we shouldn't hurt a person even if the person was bad.

3. Closing Government (CG)

• The money that the corruptors took is for their own goods.
• A lot of cases that impacted by the TH activity.

4. Closing Opposition (CO)

• TH still believe to not doing any punishment like the death penalty because it's against human rights.

THE WINNER : Opening Government because I think their arguments are related to our life.

ROUND 2

"TH would ban all pornography."

1. Opening Government (OG)

• Porn is still an evil for society, it's degrading gender relationships.
• Pornography can damage relationships, destroy families, and separate couples.

2. Opening Opposition (OO)

• It's just for sex education but only for adults.

3. Closing Government (CG)

• Pornography should be banned because it will used in a wrong way.
• Absolutely, pornography can break our minds.

4. Closing Oppositio  (CO)

• Pornography can be a business, we can take prophet from it.
• It's ok for them who are married.

THE WINNER : Opening Opposition because they gave us the data and many facts.

ROUND 3

"The reality show brings more harm."

1. Opening Government (OG)

• The reality shows do more harm than good, teenagers can stay up all night to watch their favourite the reality shows than study.
• As we can see, reality show has more moral value.

2. Opening Opposition (OO)

• The reality show is just for entertainment, the show can be motivation to who watch it.
• OO team think that reality show has less moral value.

3. Closing Government (CG)

• There's a tine where children can watch some reality shows.
• Most of them just care about ratings.

4. Closing Opposition (OO)

• The reality show brings benefit, just for entertainment and it depends how the watcher manage what they watch.
• It's not a real story, then reality show can find people who are have good talents.

THE WINNER : Closing Opposition because in my opinion they just being more realistic.

ROUND 4

"TH would not use National Examinations as a standard."

I was being a part of the Opening Opposition.